« Fill The F***ing Fab | Main | How Jobs Does It »

Sizzle, Steak and SSDs

Sell the sizzle not the steak is advertising's oldest chiche. Amended for the tech sector, it's: 'Sell version 1.0 as though it's 3.0' Or even version 100.0.

Because, the packaging suggests it performs feats which are, on occasions, technically impossible.

Look at speech recognition products. Look at the ads, or the blurb on the package, and you'd expect it to print out words which you dictate into PC.

It doesn't. I've used PC-based speech recognition for ten years, I like it, it's got much better over that time, but I know it doesn't print out the words you dictate to a PC. It prints out some of them. Others are garbled.

I once tried using a voice recorder which claimed to have dictate-to-type capabilities. It suggested that you dictated to it, then plugged it into a PC and out came the dictation.

I knew this claim was a nonsense because I was using the latest speech recognition technology on my PC, and it wasn't able to reproduce directly spoken words. Let alone words going thruogh the distorting medium of a dictaphone. .

Now we're getting the same syndrome with solid state laptops. The glories of SSD are, says the blurb: 'Smaller, faster, lighter, quicker boot, less drain on the battery blah di blah di blah'.

All true, but when it's not the storage, but the display, which is taking up most of the power requirement of a laptop, and when the form factor of the storage module is the same both for HDD as for SSD which at the moment it is, then you're not going to see such a remarkable gain in smaller, lighter, less power etc etc, as might be supposed.

At the moment SSD-based laptops are a bit like those early cars which resembled horse-drawn carriages because car designers hadn't yet figured out a more appropriate shape.

The laptop designed around an SSD looks like being a slow evolution, though Toshiba, with its 64GB SSD 779g Portege with a 12.5 hour battery life, announced this week, has made a good start.

Personally I'd like something like the old Psion 5. Fits in your inside jacket pocket. Keyboard slightly extensible to make it pacticable. Black and white screen. Ethernet port, WiFi.

The trouble is no manufacturer would have the discipline to avoid putting in a phone function, a camera, gaming, a GPS and goodness knows what besides.

They just don't know when to stop.


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.electronicsweekly.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/7421

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on June 22, 2007 1:55 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Fill The F***ing Fab.

The next post in this blog is How Jobs Does It.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Sign up for the new weekly Mannerisms eNewsletter. Get the latest posts straight to your email inbox, no fuss. Tick the option for Semiconductor commentary.

RSS Subscribe to this blog's feed
[What is this?]

Recent Comments

Archives

Go back to ElectronicsWeekly.com