« Ed The Serial CEO Makes A Conference Presentation | Main | Motorola Makes First European CMOS IC »

Cloud Computing Founders On Hottentot Networks

A little while back I was in California listening to a seminar on mobile data services in automobiles. The prospect of a wide range of data services to be delivered to car drivers and passengers was discussed. The prospect of a multi-tens-of-billions-of -dollars market was anticipated.

 

I really wanted to say something like: 'This market won't happen because, however good the services are, the American wireless networks are too flaky to deliver them'.

 

But I thought it would be rude for a foreigner to say such a thing.

 

Since then I've marvelled at the happy talk of Cloud Computing: Huge market; Allows small, portable, OS-agnostic, computing devices; brings in New Nomadic Age. That sort of thing.

 

Now just look at this story from CNET: T-Mobile users cut off for a month.

 

Pity the Nomadic surfer deprived of his wave.

 

Even at the best of times, the US wireless networks are barely capable of sustaining conversations. When it comes to them delivering data, the mind boggles.

 

It's the same over here. The networks get clogged with traffic but the operators lag behind the demand in upgrading the networks. Outside major inner-city areas, GPRS is the UK norm.

 

So, as traffic increases, calls drop, connections can't be made, data transfer rates are painfully slow.

 

And the 21st century dream of Cloud Computing founders on a Hottentot network.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.electronicsweekly.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/70783

Comments (4)

Simonsse:

East Coast mainline trains from National Express "Free wifi on-board for all passengers", yeah right.

800 people all sucking on an 11mb/s (sorry should be Mb/s, but it definitely felt like mb/s) link. Worked better with the flaky 3G-wifi bridge on my Nokia (and that was poor). Won't be rushing back to that as a USP...

All together "Wireless doesn't work".

David Manners Author Profile Page:

Simonsse you are so, so right. And it's so annoying. It's very common in very many WiFi installations, in my experience - the installers take no account of the likely number of users. Result: misery for everyone (except the lucky b. who gets on first).

Mike Bryant:

I suspect if the East Coast regularly had 800 passengers on the train then a) they wouldn't have gone bankrupt and b) they'd provide multiple links. Actually getting uninterupted high speed wireless to a 125mph train is a feat in itself and a very expensive one at that. I think we forget the grief of only 10 years ago playing with modem cables under hotel beds trying to download our e-mail to a laptop which didn't really want to do it.

David Manners Author Profile Page:

Indeed I do remember it Mike, and a miserable process it was. But while we've moved on a mile since then, I still wouldn't like to have to rely on a wireless link to get my OS, application software and stored files every time I turn on a portable computer. I was amazed to find out how little 3G there actually is.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on November 10, 2009 2:45 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Ed The Serial CEO Makes A Conference Presentation.

The next post in this blog is Motorola Makes First European CMOS IC.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Sign up for the new weekly Mannerisms eNewsletter. Get the latest posts straight to your email inbox, no fuss. Tick the option for Semiconductor commentary.

RSS Subscribe to this blog's feed
[What is this?]
ElectronicsNews on Twitter Follow ElectronicsNews on Twitter

Advertisement


Recent Comments

David Manners on Cloud Computing Founders On Hottentot Networks: Indeed I do remember it Mike, and a mise
Mike Bryant on Cloud Computing Founders On Hottentot Networks: I suspect if the East Coast regularly ha
David Manners on Cloud Computing Founders On Hottentot Networks: Simonsse you are so, so right. And it's
Simonsse on Cloud Computing Founders On Hottentot Networks: East Coast mainline trains from National

Archives