When is a door not a door?*

“Are the doors wrong or the balconies? Conflict between planners, architects and builders?” A good question.

door-window-2.jpgPanda” is a good friend of the Made By Monkeys blog and he’s recently sent us this one.

He asks: “Are the doors wrong or the balconies? Conflict between planners, architects and builders?” A good question, as I’ve seen this repeated elsewhere (for example, modern flat blocks in Sutton, Surrey).

If door’s could speak, these would have an identity problem: “I am a door not a window…”

Can anyone shed light on the matter?

* When it’s ajar

Comments

9 comments

  1. Stick a pipe out the wall, no one will notice

    “Just spotted this air con exhaust pipe coming out of the middle of the wall on our walk today,” he writes. “Very weird.”

  2. When is a door not a door?
    When it’s a French window.

  3. Also handy if the hot water tank needs to be replaced.

  4. It could be a door for large furniture/pianos, etc which could be lifted in by crane if stair well is small and it could be a window for the rest of the time.

  5. I’ve seen these type of features on many different buildings – not just modern ones. I’ve always regarded them as floor-length windows, giving you extra light and window space, but not requiring the extra structural requirements that a true balcony requires.

  6. “The idea being that the fire brigade can put a ladder against these to help someone out.” That would be very practical, James. Never thought of that. I can’t help thinking, though, that fire regulations must allow full exit by other means anyway.

  7. Thanks John, interesting. It’s kind of a poor-man’s “Juliet”, though. And, of course, the door must always open inwards or there’ll be no show (!)

  8. Are these not fire escapes? Is the rule for new windows that a certain number of windows on each floor open to a suitable degree (i.e. a full 90 degrees open) to allow emergency access (or escape). The idea being that the fire brigade can put a ladder against these to help someone out. Why use a full door AND railing I don’t know, and I’m sure as John points out, fashion has a lot to do with it.

  9. As an engineer by day, and a local councillor on the Planning Committee in the evenings, I’ve seen lots of these on refurbs and new buildings.

    I think they’re sometimes referred to as a “Juliet balcony” and are (I’ve always assumed) designed by architects to satisfy the aspirations of developers and flat-buyers who aspire to that royal/Hollywood wave-to-the-crowds experience, but are building where a proper projecting balcony wouldn’t be allowed for planning, structural or cost reasons. Given that the door (not window) is there, and opens, the need for the railings should be obvious…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>